Note: We have made every effort to offer the most convenient schedules for your trip to and from Fire Island. In some instances there are no connecting services (where the LIRR schedule service and the Sayville Ferry schedule coincide at a reasonable time), or alternate services available.
As for alternates, in most instances convenient connections can be made through Ronkonkoma Station - and we have noted on the Fairy Schedule. Ronkonkoma Station can be reached by taxi in about 15 minutes ($19). Occasionally the bus service will choose to take you to Ronkonkoma Station rather than Sayville Station.
Long Island Railroad (LIRR) Fare from Penn (or Atlantic) to Sayville - 2015 Fares
|Type of Ticket||Station/TVM||On Board||WebTicket|
|Ten Trip Peak||$182.50||N/A||$182.50|
|Off Peak Ten Trip||$112.75||N/A||$112.75|
|Ten Trip Senior/Disabled/Medicare||$90.00||N/A||$90.00|
Peak Fares are charged during business rush hours, on any weekday train scheduled
to arrive in NYC terminals between 6 and 10 AM or depart NYC terminals between 4 and 8 PM.
Off Peak Fares are charged all other times on weekdays,
all day on Saturdays and Sundays and holidays.
Walk to the Ferry (map) - On a nice day with 30 minutes or more to spare, a brisk walk to the ferry can take 25 minutes.
Transfer to Ferry: Bus $5 / Taxi $6
(meets all incoming trains and ferries)
$19 to/from Ronkonkoma LIRR Train station
$20 to/from Islip Airport
41 River Road
Sayville, NY 117782-0626
- Round trip $16 - round trip required (yep, it went up! Your Commutation Fare Card (40 trips) is still valid. Lucky you!
- Dog (any size) $4.50/ea
Bus Service (to and from Manhattan)
Colonial occasionally runs a Monday trip to Manhattan (Penn Station) from the 12noon ferry. $20. Arrives about 2pm - a 90 minute ride.
You have to inquire at (888)451-9511 to see if the service will be offered, and which ferry it will meet.
Water Taxi (to/from Cherry Grove and The Pines, or from Bayshore, no service from Sayville)
South Bay / 631-665-8885
Aqualine / 631-665-5566
Emergencies Dial 911 , then 1-631-597-6160
577 Coast Guard Walk
Whyte Hall Community Center
Emergencies Dial 911 , then 1-631-597-6767
Cherry Grove Medical Clinic
Grove Liquor (Dune & Ocean Walk)
Pines Liquor (Hours same as Pines Pantry)
Summer Solstice - Gifts & Clothing
“Upstairs above The Pantry”
Fire Island Business Directory (Pines & Grove)
Whether you want to talk or text, use wireless Internet, or just in need of using your "buddy finding" app. Here's the low-down on what to expect:
Mobile Phone Services
Note: This is an island.
Despite the location mobile phone service has improved in recent years. Most cell towers are located on the mainland near Sayville. So the bay-side, or houses on higher elevations will have better reception than beach-side houses.
Coverage by service:
|Service Provider||Mobile Service||Data Service|
|Verizon *||excellent||up to 4G LTE|
|T-Mobile||good||up to 4G|
* Verizon has cell towers on Whyte Hall
** AT&T Micro Cells are available locally through TPP Wireless for $15/month (TPP Wireless account required)
Note again: This is an island.
We are all sharing a link to the mainland, and that signal is wirelessly transmitted around the community. Given the circumstances the service works surprisingly well, however, it is effected by weather (rain, fog, and heat) and the number of users at any given time.
TPP Wireless (operated by Pines Pantry) - Hourly, daily, and seasonal residential service available. Dedicated technical support.
Service covers Cherry Grove, The Pines, and Water Island.
Contact Pine Pantry for more information at 631-597-6200 or TPPWireless
Barrier Free offers Residential Service at (800) 982-3841
Add The Fairy Schedule to your mobile phone or tablet.
Have access to The Fairy Schedule just about wherever you are.
Find out when your train leaves from NY Penn or Brooklyn, and which ferry you will meet to get to Cherry Grove or The Pines. The reverse schedule will get you back to NY on time.
Navigate to Cherry Grove and Pines schedules, and other options, by clicking on the appropriate text.
For best results navigate the Ferry Schedule in landscape, or horizontal position.